Legal aid, referral services, and private attorneys answer different questions, so each one needs a different first conversation. With legal aid, ask whether you qualify and whether the office has capacity. With a referral service, ask what the referral costs and what happens after the first meeting. With a private attorney, ask exactly what work you are paying for and how the fee works. The comparison and question lists below show what to confirm with each one in New York City.
How the three options compare
| Point to compare | Legal aid or nonprofit provider | Bar referral service | Private attorney |
|---|---|---|---|
| Role | Provides free legal help to people who meet its program rules | Screens your question and may connect you with a participating lawyer | Represents you under an agreement you make directly |
| Who decides | The organization, based on funding, issue, capacity, and household details | A counselor decides whether a referral fits; you decide whether to hire the lawyer | You and the lawyer both have to agree |
| Typical cost | Free if accepted | At the NYC Bar service, $35 or free for up to 30 minutes, depending on the type of case | Set by your agreement |
| Scope | May range from brief advice or a referral to representation | The first consultation; further work is a separate agreement | Whatever the engagement letter or retainer describes |
| Confirm first | Eligibility, whether your case type is open, and the next step after screening | Whether your case type is fee-exempt and how payment works | Fee, expenses, billing, and what is excluded |
Questions for legal aid and nonprofit providers
Eligibility is often more complicated than an income figure. Legal Services NYC says it primarily assists low-income households, but its income rules vary by funding source. Eligibility can also depend on the legal issue, program capacity, immigration status, and other details. Its Access Line, 917-661-4500, can complete an initial screening and sometimes give brief advice, and the organization states that there is no guarantee of ongoing help or full representation (Legal Services NYC). Other providers set their own rules, so ask:
- Do you handle this type of problem in my borough right now?
- What income, household, or other requirements apply to this program?
- Does anything about my immigration status change which program can help?
- Would help mean advice, a clinic, or a lawyer on my case?
- When will I hear back, and what should I do if my date arrives first?
- If you cannot help, who should I call next?
Some legal rights work differently. If you cannot afford a lawyer in a criminal case, the court assigns one at arraignment (Legal Aid Society). State law also requires free representation for people who cannot afford a lawyer in certain Family Court matters (NY Office of Indigent Legal Services). NYC tenants facing eviction can seek free legal representation or advice through Right to Counsel, by calling 311 and asking for the Tenant Helpline (HRA).
Questions for a referral service
A referral service is a way to find a lawyer, and the NYC Bar’s own materials do not describe it as a low-income program. At the New York City Bar Legal Referral Service, speaking with a counselor and receiving a referral are free. Counselors review your situation and may suggest other resources if a lawyer is not needed. The consultation costs $35 or is free depending on the case type, and lasts up to 30 minutes. You provide a card before the referral, and it is charged only after the consultation is confirmed. Hiring the lawyer afterward is your choice, and further fees are agreed with the lawyer before that work starts (NYC Bar FAQ; Request a Lawyer). The service lists 212-626-7373 for English and 212-626-7374 for Spanish. Ask:
- Does my type of case qualify for the free consultation?
- What happens to the card hold if the meeting never takes place?
- How long is the consultation, and can I bring someone or use an interpreter?
- Does the referred lawyer practice in the court or agency involved in my matter?
- What would continuing with this lawyer cost, and when would that be decided?
Check the rules of any other referral service separately. The New York State Bar Association’s service, for example, works through an online form and has its own list of fee exceptions, and its staff are not attorneys (NYSBA).
Questions for a private attorney
New York’s engagement-letter rule gives you a useful framework. Unless an exception applies, a lawyer charging a fee must provide a written letter of engagement before representation begins. The rule permits delivery within a reasonable time afterward if earlier delivery is otherwise impracticable or the scope of services cannot yet be determined. The letter must explain the scope of the services, the fees, expenses, and billing practices, and any right to arbitrate fee disputes, and a significant change in scope or fee calls for an update. A signed retainer agreement covering the same points can be used instead (22 NYCRR § 1215.1).
The rule has exceptions. It does not apply when the fee is expected to be under $3,000, when the work is the same general kind the client has already hired and paid the lawyer for, or in domestic relations matters governed by Part 1400 (22 NYCRR § 1215.2). Domestic relations clients receive a statement of client’s rights and responsibilities at the initial conference, before signing a retainer (22 NYCRR § 1400.2). You can ask for the terms in writing even when the rule does not require it. Ask:
- Exactly what will you do, and what is left out?
- Does this cover hearings, appeals, or only one stage?
- Is the fee hourly, flat, or something else, and who does the work?
- What expenses will I pay, and how often will I be billed?
- What will the likely next steps and dates be?
- Are you licensed in New York, and have you handled this kind of matter?
For more on fee arrangements, see attorney fees explained.
If something goes wrong with a lawyer
Fee disagreements and ethics complaints follow different routes. New York’s fee dispute program generally covers civil matters involving $1,000 to $50,000, and it excludes criminal matters and claims of malpractice or misconduct, among others (22 NYCRR § 137.1). Attorney Grievance Committees address ethical conduct, and they cannot sue a lawyer for you or seek the return of your money. NYC Bar lists the committee for Manhattan and the Bronx at 212-401-0800 and the committee for Brooklyn, Queens, and Staten Island at 718-923-6300 (NYSBA guide; NYC Bar).
Your next step
Choose the route that fits your budget and deadline, copy its question list, and call. If a free route is your first choice, begin with our overview of legal aid organizations or pro bono services. To plan a paid meeting, see our consultation tips, and return to NYC legal resources for other options. CalmJustice provides legal-resource education and does not claim any referral agreement or attorney relationship with the organizations named here.
Sources
- Legal Services NYC, Our Intake Process
- NYC Bar Legal Referral Service, FAQ
- NYC Bar, Request a Lawyer
- NYSBA Lawyer Referral Service
- NYSBA, Guide to Attorney Discipline
- NYC Bar, Complaints About Lawyers and Judges
- 22 NYCRR § 1215.1, § 1215.2, § 137.1, and § 1400.2 (Cornell LII)
- NY Office of Indigent Legal Services, Eligibility
- The Legal Aid Society, Finding a Lawyer
- NYC HRA, Legal Services for Tenants
