Reading an Itemized Security Deposit Deduction Statement

Read a deduction statement in two passes: first reconcile the money, then examine the factual basis for each charge. Match each line to a particular room, condition, and supporting record. You can identify missing explanations without deciding on your own that a charge is lawful or unlawful.

This is New York legal-resource education checked November 5, 2026. It is not advice about your particular deductions. Readers outside New York should check local law. Our Security Deposits resources explain the surrounding topic.

Identify the document and preserve its timing

Is this the proposed list from the pre-vacating inspection, a final itemization, or only a payment notification? Save the entire document, envelope, email, and attachments. Record when you vacated, when the statement was sent and received, and when any refund arrived. Do not silently substitute the lease-end date for the vacating date.

For covered rentals, § 7-107(6) and § 7-108(1-a)(e) require itemization and remaining security within 14 days after vacating. Failure carries statutory forfeiture of retention rights. Application and enforcement require case-specific review; seek prompt legal help if timing is disputed or a deadline is near.

The stabilized-unit rule is current law, not an exception to the deadline. Rent control, special facilities, and housing-program rules still require attention to statutory scope. If you cannot identify your housing status, put that uncertainty at the top of the review sheet.

Reconcile the numbers before arguing about condition

Start with the deposit actually paid, supported by your receipt or transfer record. List each claimed deduction, total them, and compare that total with the amount withheld. Record any separately explained interest. Then compare the expected balance on the statement with what actually reached you. A calculation mismatch and a disagreement over damage are separate issues.

Fictional arithmetic example: A statement starts with a $2,000 deposit and lists $180 for cleaning and $320 for a door. The listed deductions total $500, leaving $1,500 before any separately applicable interest. If the payment received is $1,400, there is an unexplained $100 difference. This example checks bookkeeping only; it does not endorse either deduction or calculate anyone’s entitlement.

Classify what each line claims

The current statutes distinguish unpaid rent, tenant damage beyond ordinary wear, utilities payable directly to the landlord under the tenancy, and moving or storage costs. Ordinary wear and prior-tenant damage are excluded. A label such as “restoration” does not identify the condition, cause, or amount. Compare the stated reason with your records before responding.

For a rent entry, compare the claimed month with payment records and any ledger. For a utility entry, locate the lease provision and bill. For a repair, identify the object, alleged damage, move-in condition, and work charged. A photograph may show a mark without explaining how much work was performed or why the whole replacement cost was attributed to you.

Use a line-by-line review worksheet

Item and amount Evidence requested Tenant record Question and response date
Exact wording: ______; amount: ______ Specific location, work, invoice or calculation: ______ Photo ID, agreement, payment, message: ______ What remains unexplained: ______; reply received: ______
Fictional example: door repair, $320 Which door; work description; repair receipt Move-in door photograph and inspection note Does the charge concern the same condition shown at move-in? Reply date: ______

Add one row for every deduction, including repeated descriptions. If two entries concern the same object, ask how the work differs. Mark your position “agree,” “dispute,” or “need information,” with a reason. Uncertainty is useful when it names the missing fact; it is less useful when recorded simply as “unfair.”

Ask for documents that answer a specific question

The Attorney General’s deposit guidance suggests gathering rent-payment proof and requesting repair receipts when damage is alleged. Request the records tied to your disputed lines. Do not describe every requested document as something the statute necessarily requires to accompany the itemization.

Keep an estimate distinct from a paid invoice, and a replacement purchase distinct from evidence of why replacement was needed. The NYC Small Claims Court preparation guidance identifies photographs, agreements, receipts, paid invoices, and repair estimates among possible evidence. Their significance depends on the dispute; collecting them guarantees no result.

Write a focused response

Organize your message in this order: identify the apartment and statement date; acknowledge the amount actually received; name the specific disputed or unexplained lines; refer to your matching records; request a corrected accounting or explanation. Attach only relevant copies and keep the originals.

A neutral sentence might read: “The cabinet entry appears to concern the peeled edge shown in the signed move-in condition record, entry K03. Please explain the work charged and provide the related receipt.” This is a writing example, not a legal conclusion about the charge.

Your next action is to complete one worksheet row before drafting the whole response. For assistance, use the first-call preparation guide and alternative legal-resource organizer. Broader navigation is available through Housing Issues and CalmJustice.

Sources